Table of Contents
View All
View All
Dabba Trading Meaning
How Does Dabba Trading Work?
Why Do Investors Get into Dabba Trading?
Attributes of Dabba Trading
Dabba Trading vs Legal Trading
What is Delivery Trading and How Does It Work?
Difference Between Dabba Trading and Delivery Trading
Risks of Dabba Trading
Conclusion
The stock market offers various opportunities for investors, but some choose to engage in risky and unregulated practices in hopes of making quick profits. One such practice is dabba trading, which operates outside official stock exchanges. While it may seem tempting to some, dabba trading comes with significant risks.
This blog will help you understand how dabba trading works, why some investors get involved despite its dangers, and why avoiding these illegal trading methods is crucial to protect your investments.
Dabba trading is an illegal practice in which trades occur off the official stock market. Instead of using formal exchanges like the NSE or BSE, a broker runs the operation, keeping records in a “dabba” (box). This means there’s no transparency, and the trades don’t reflect on the official exchange.
Investors place their orders with the broker, who then manages the trades without actually executing them on the official exchange. While this might seem convenient for some, it’s incredibly risky because there’s no regulation or security.
In Dabba trading, investors bet on stock prices instead of buying the actual stocks. Here’s a simple breakdown of how this system works:
Also Read: What is IPO in Trading?
Investors are often drawn to Dabba trading for a variety of reasons despite its risks and illegal nature. Here are some of the key factors that attract people to this risky trading method:
Many investors see Dabba trading as a shortcut to fast gains. Since it bypasses the formal processes and regulations of stock exchanges, traders believe they can make money faster than through regular stock market trading.
Unlike official trading platforms, Dabba trading doesn’t require lengthy paperwork, KYC (Know Your Customer) processes, or other formalities. This appeals to people who want to avoid bureaucratic hurdles and start trading right away.
Some investors prefer using cash for trading to avoid taxes or maintain anonymity. In Dabba trading, cash deals are common, making it a choice for those who want to keep their trades off the radar.
Brokers involved in Dabba trading often offer high leverage, allowing traders to place large bets with small amounts of money. The prospect of potentially high returns with little initial investment is a major attraction for risk-takers.
Since Dabba trading is done off the books, investors don’t have to pay taxes, brokerage fees, or other mandatory charges in official trading. The idea of saving money on taxes and fees can lure many people into this illegal trading method.
Dabba trading has some distinct and risky characteristics that set it apart from regular stock market trading. Here are the key attributes:
Dabba trading is not recognised or approved by SEBI (Securities and Exchange Board of India) or any other legal authority, making it a completely illegal practice.
Most Dabba trading is done using cash. Since it operates outside the formal banking system, there’s no paper trail, which makes it hard to detect or track.
In Dabba trading, investors never own the stocks they are trading. Instead, they merely bet on stock price movements without purchasing the real shares.
The brokers involved in Dabba trading are not registered with SEBI. This means they operate outside the legal system with no accountability or oversight.
Since it’s unregulated, there’s a much higher risk for investors. Without legal protection or safeguards, they are vulnerable to fraud, loss of money, or other serious consequences.
Check out the key differences between legal trading and Dabba trading:
Point of Distinction | Legal Trading | Dabba Trading |
Legality | All kinds of legal trading are regulated and directed by the rules and regulations of SEBI. | Dabba Trading is unregulated and illegal; this kind of trading is done outside the official stock exchange. |
Transparency | All the trading transactions are recorded to provide clarity. | Transactions are not recorded, making it more unclear. |
Risks | It can be handled through risk management techniques and SEBI rules. | Inclined to higher risks due to the total lack of any regulatory body. |
Taxation | Traders are under different types of tax obligations. | There are no tax obligations. |
Requirements | A trading and demat account are needed. | It does not require a trading or Demat account, as all transactions are settled in cash outside the stock exchange. |
Unlike dabba trading, where trades happen outside the official stock market and are not registered, delivery trading is fully transparent and safe. Investors own the shares they purchase and benefit from dividends, long-term growth, and rights issues. It involves buying and holding stocks longer than a single trading day. You can own these shares for as long as you wish, even for years.
Point of Distinction | Dabba Trading | Delivery Trading |
Trade Execution | As dabba trading occurs outside the official stock market, the rules and regulations of stock exchanges don’t apply. | Through registered stock exchanges and all the rules and regulations of stock exchanges do apply. |
Legality | It is illegal in India | It is legal and regulated by SEBI |
Risk Factor | The risk is exceptionally high due to no investor protection | Risk is moderate, with regulatory protection |
Tax Implications | In the case of dabba trading, it avoids taxes | There is proper taxation on capital gains |
The risks of dabba trading are significant and could lead to huge losses. Here’s why:
Risk | Description | Impact |
No Legal Protection | Since Dabba trading is illegal, investors have no legal recourse in case of fraud or disputes. | There is a high risk of losing all invested money without any chance of recovery. |
Risk of Fraud | Unregulated brokers can easily manipulate transactions or disappear with investor funds. | Investors can be cheated with no accountability or transparency. |
No Regulatory Oversight | There is no SEBI or regulatory body overseeing these transactions. | A complete lack of safeguards exposes investors to unfair practices and illegal activities. |
Cash-Based Trading | Most trades are done in cash to avoid detection, which increases the risk of untraceable losses. | Hard to track, making it difficult for investors to monitor or control their funds. |
High Leverage | Brokers often offer high leverage, which can amplify both gains and losses. | Small losses can quickly become large debts, leaving investors in financial trouble. |
Dabba trading might seem tempting due to its promises of quick profits and low costs, but it’s a dangerous and illegal practice. You could lose everything you invest, and there’s no legal protection if something goes wrong. Although legal trading platforms may come with some fees, they offer transparency, security, and regulated trading, which is the safest way to invest in the stock market. It’s always better to stay away from such illegal activities and invest through recognised legal channels.
A seasoned investment professional with over 17 years of experience in AIF and PMS operations, investments, and research analysis. Abhishek holds an Executive MBA from the Faculty of Management Studies, University of Delhi, and has deep expertise in securities analysis, portfolio management, financial analytics, reporting and derivatives.
Disclaimer: This information is for general information purposes only. Investments in the securities market are subject to market risks, read all the related documents carefully before investing.
Impress your coworkers with your finance insights
20 MinsMutual Funds
A Beginner's Guide to Mutual Funds in 2024
8 MinsSIPs
How SIPs Help You Beat the Market with Rupee Cost Averaging
11 MinsSIPs
SIP vs. Lumpsum Mutual Fund Returns: Which is Better?